The Importance of Context with Marketing Experiments

By now most marketers are familiar with the process of experimentation, identify a hypothesis, design a test that splits the population across one or more variants and select a winning variation based on a success metric. This “winner” has a heavy responsibility – we’re assuming that it confers the improvement in revenue and conversion that we measured during the experiment.

The experiments that you run have to result in better decisions, and ultimately ROI. Further down we’ll look at a situations where an external validity threat in the form of a separate campaign would have invalidated the results of a traditional A/B test. In addition, I’ll show how we were able to adjust and even exploit this external factor using a predictive optimization approach which resulted in a Customer Lifetime Value (LTV) increase of almost 70%.

(more…)

By |2020-01-28T08:41:14-08:00January 28th, 2020|Conversion Rate Optimization, B2B, Experimentation|0 Comments

Optimization Pitfalls to Avoid In 2020

The Activity Trap

Sales reps aren’t paid on the number of calls they make, and real estate agents don’t get commission on the number of showings they do. Activity does not equate to outcome, and conflating the two can have really expensive implications.

The same story applies to marketers. We seem to spend a lot of effort fostering cultures of activity rather than outcomes.

(more…)

How Not Picking an Experiment Winner Led to a 227% Increase in Revenue

By now most marketers are familiar with the process of experimentation, identify a hypothesis, design a test that splits the population across one or more variants and select a winning variation based on a success metric. This “winner” has a heavy responsibility – we’re assuming that it confers the improvement in revenue and conversion that we measured during the experiment.

Is this always the case? As marketers we’re often told to look at the scientific community as the gold standard for rigorous experimental methodology. But it’s informative to take a look at where even medical testing has come up short.

For years women have been chronically underrepresented in medical trials, which disproportionately favors males in the testing population. This selection bias in medical testing extends back to pre-clinical stages – the majority of drug development research being done on male-only lab animals.

And this testing bias has had real-world consequences. A 2001 report found that 80% of the FDA-approved drugs pulled from the market for “unacceptable health risks” were found to be more harmful to women than to men. In 2013 the FDA announced revised dosing recommendations of the sleep aid Ambien, after finding that women were susceptible to risks resulting from slower metabolism of the medication.

This is a specific example of the problem of external validity in experimentation which poses a risk even if a randomized experiment is conducted appropriately and it’s possible to infer cause and effect conclusions (internal validity.) If the sampled population does not represent the broader population, then those conclusions are likely to be compromised.

Although they’re unlikely to pose a life-or-death scenario, external validity threats are very real risks to marketing experimentation. That triple digit improvement you saw within the test likely won’t produce the expected return when implemented. Ensuring test validity can be a challenging and resource intensive process, fortunately however it’s possible to decouple your return from many of these external threats entirely.

The experiments that you run have to result in better decisions, and ultimately ROI. Further down we’ll look at a situation where an external validity threat in the form of a separate campaign would have invalidated the results of a traditional A/B test. In addition, I’ll show how we were able to adjust and even exploit this external factor using a predictive optimization approach which resulted in a Customer Lifetime Value (LTV) increase of almost 70%.

(more…)

Understanding the CMOs Data-Driven Decision Delusion

The term cobra effect describes an incentive policy that causes unintended consequences and results in the opposite effect intended. In the 1800s the colonial government of India (as the story goes), becoming increasingly concerned about the population of cobras in Delhi, offered a bounty for every dead cobra brought in.

Although it was initially successful, the cobra population increased as entrepreneurs of the day started breeding cobras to take advantage of the bounty. When the government realized the new policy wasn’t working as intended they ended the program, causing the cobra farmers to release the snakes and further exacerbating the very problem the government wanted to solve.

I recently read Chief Marketing Officers at Work, a fantastic series of interviews of CMOs from prominent companies like PayPal, Zendesk, Domo and SurveyMonkey. These marketing leaders unequivocally championed their data-driven marketing strategies, and emphasized the need for further data-driven investment and skills in their organizations.

The root cause of many cobra effect problems is the fact that as humans we tend to more easily comprehend simplistic linear systems and cause-effect relationships. Much like rewarding people for killing cobras should result in less cobras, investing in more data-driven tools should produce better decisions and outcomes!

Unfortunately, it’s very likely that the data-driven approaches being increasingly adopted by marketing organizations are producing their own cobra effect and paradoxically reducing the quality of decisions and resulting outcomes.

(more…)

By |2018-10-20T22:54:43-07:00September 24th, 2018|Digital Marketing, Strategy, B2B|0 Comments

A Culture of Optimization Eats Experimentation and Personalization for Breakfast

 

As marketers we could learn a lot from ants.

They don’t attend conferences, have multi-million dollar budgets or get pitched by the latest AI-based tech vendors. Yet over millennia they’ve figured out a radically efficient solution to an important and complex problem – how best to find food to sustain the colony.

This is no easy task. The first ant leaving the colony walks around in a random pattern. It’s likely he (foraging ants are always male) doesn’t find food, so he’ll return back to the colony exhausted. It’s not a completely wasted effort however, he (and every other ant behind him) will leave behind a pheromone trail that attracts other ants.

Over the course of time and thousands of individual ant voyages, food will (likely) be found. Ants that do find food will return immediately back to the colony. Other ants will follow this trail and, because pheromone trails evaporate over time, they’re most likely to follow the shortest, most traveled (highest density) path.

This approach ensures that the colony as a whole will find an optimal path to a food source. Pheromone evaporation also helps ensure that if the current source runs out, or a closer one is found, the colony will continue to evolve to the globally optimal solution.

It’s a classic optimization solution that maximizes a critical outcome as efficiently as possible, and one that has been studied by entomologists, computer engineers and data scientists. In the current B2B marketing environment it can illuminate where we’re spending our time and money.

(more…)

The Reason Your B2B Website is No Longer Effective

The 1907 Quakers from the University of Pennsylvania were the juggernauts of college football. Heading into a home field matchup with the Carlisle Indians they had not only won, but dominated their previous seven games by a combined score of 189-10.

Their October home game on Franklin field against Carlisle wasn’t expected to be much different. Although the Indians were also undefeated, they were a group of unheralded, undersized players that the 22,800 fans in attendance didn’t give much of a chance against their mighty Quakers.

So what happened? Carlisle demolished Penn 26-6. The most notable play of the game was fullback Pete Hauer’s 40 yard perfect spiral pass that sports historians would later call one of the “three or four signal moments in the evolution of football” and “the sporting equivalent of the Wright brothers taking off at Kitty Hawk.”

These historians attribute Carlisle’s stunning upset that Saturday to Carlisle coach Pop Warner’s exploitation of a rule change that was adopted a couple of years earlier. In order to curb the surging violence in football schools adopted a number of rules changes, most notably legalizing the forward pass.

Warner decisively capitalized on this rule change, confusing the Quakers with long passes and new formations. Penn was playing by the old rules, and caught completely unprepared for the new era of football that they had the misfortune of writing into history that day.

(more…)

By |2018-10-20T21:47:07-07:00March 7th, 2018|B2B, Uncategorized, The Funnel, Strategy, SaaS|0 Comments

If you care about B2B conversions, stop producing content

Houston, we have a problem.

As enterprise focused B2B marketers, we have a problem.

We all agree that we want to grow traffic to our website, turn the traffic into leads and convert the leads into customers.

Yet, we have all blindly trusted the theory that, producing more content, showing product options, displaying more testimonials, and creating more case studies will get you a bigger pipeline.   

Let us be the first to refute this claim: more is not better.

In fact, with every additional piece of content or white paper you are killing pipeline. Why, might ask?

Because you are simply overwhelming your customers.

Explanation please!?

To illustrate this point, let’s talk about Cognitive Load.

Cognitive load refers to the total amount of mental effort being used in the working memory.

When we put irrelevant, unnecessary and distracting information in front of people, we fill up that working memory. The result is a decreased ability to absorb information, learn and ultimately make decisions.

While it may seem that having multiple content options on your website increases the likelihood that you will connect with your visitor, it actually has the opposite effect.

When customers are given too many content options you are forcing them to make decisions that take up their mental resources, derailing your chance at a direct path to purchasing.

Can someone say cognitive overload?!

Think about it this way: the most important factor in the design of a website is making it easier for customer to find what they want. Customers crave simple and easy navigation over anything else in regard to design.

most important factors in the design of a website

Most important factors in the design of a website

If your website presents multiple decisions for the user, you filled with decisions for users to make, you are not making it easy for them to find what they want!

Let’s break it down.

Let’s take a look at some examples unintentionally cognitive overload.

Content.

As marketers, we are producing too much content that is both expensive and unnecessary.

In reality, only a small portion of your content is necessary to help the customer move down the purchase funnel and it is our job as marketers to present that one (perfect) piece of content. Sadly, we are letting our customers down by allowing them to read irrelevant content and thus, introducing cognitive load.

produce more content

Produce more content

Calls to action.

While letting visitors chose from multiple CTA’s may seem like a great way to help customers find what they want, it actually leads them to confusion. Rather, you should be putting them on a specific path that you have identified as most effective for conversions.

Calls to Action

Multiple calls to action

Product options.

If you’re selling an enterprise focused product, it is likely that your website is showcasing all of the products and services that you offer. Again, this overwhelms customers. 

We should know about our customers well enough so that we are only showing the products that we believe (based on research) they are likely to buy! Don’t give them fifty options and hope their first selection is the one best suited for them.

analytic solutions

Analytic Solution

Case studies.

A customer only works in one industry; do not show them case studies from other industries where the use cases might be completely different. This content is irrelevant, distracting and increases cognitive load.

case studies

All case studies

Industry solutions.

We are asking customers to unnecessarily identify themselves. Having to go through a selection process, like the example below, does not inspire confidence that the software is well suited for a visitor’s industry.

industry solutions

Industry Solutions

  

Pricing options.

A multitude of pricing options is a perfect example of cognitive overload. We are overwhelming our customers with pricing options to the point where they don’t know which option to choose.

Target enterprise accounts shouldn’t see basic pricing tiers. Similarly, SMB’s shouldn’t see enterprise offerings. This substandard experience increases friction and reduces conversion rates!

pricing options

pricing options

 

It is time to stop – your are overwhelming your Customers.

So, what’s the solution then? How do we make sure customers aren’t overwhelmed with cognitive overload?

It’s simple: reduce content and only show the most relevant information.

Calls to Action

Calls to Action

 

Keeping this in mind, what if instead of showing everything to all of our visitors, we only showed the most relevant and effective calls to action?

Logos and Testimonials

Logos & Testimonials

  

What if we show the logos and testimonials that were most relevant to customer needs or highlighted the testimonials that most reflected their pain points?

pricing plans

Pricing Plans

What if we focused on and only showed the pricing that was going to be relevant for the given account and the features of those plans that were going to meet their needs?

customer experience

Customer Experience

What if we only showed customers relevant experiences based on what we knew about them? 

Doing things right

Doing things right

Doing this right has real and meaningful implications. 94% of buyers in a Demand Gen survey choose the winning vendor because that company demonstrated a stronger knowledge of their needs.

In an Accenture survey, half of B2B customers already expect improved personalized product or service recommendations. In fact, 65% of business buyers are likely to switch brands if a company doesn’t make an effort to personalize communications to their business.

The takeaways.

The more options you give customers, the more cognitive load you put on them. The result is a filled-up working memory and hindered ability to make decisions toward purchasing a product. 

Instead of producing more content, focus on showing the single experience that will resonate most with your customers!

 

Pricing Page Conversion Tips

If you are a B2B SAAS business you should be spending a lot of time on your pricing page focused on iterative testing.

Pricing pages are vital for your bottom line. Those who end up there are late in the conversion funnel, and likely gathering the information to make a purchase decision, or at least consider that purchase.

Given its importance, you should be constantly A/B testing pricing pages, taking every incremental improvement as a win for your marketing department.

At a high level, pricing pages should be clear in terms of quickly getting users information to make a purchase decision and also not introduce additional points of friction. While simple in theory to follow, we see many of these fundamental rules not being followed here at FunnelEnvy.

As such, we have created a simple list of best practices you should follow to maximize conversions with your pricing pages.

Clear and Simple Pricing Tier Design

The specific pricing tiers on a pricing page is often an acute area of focus for testing, and somewhere that you might want to spend lots of time on.

Here are 3 helpful steps to follow with your pricing page design.

  1. Focus on clarity and simplicity.
  2. Ensure the design conveys the most critical information about those pricing tiers in order for the user to make a purchase decision.
  3. Keep the calls to action clear and differentiated enough to stand out.  

I’m going to use two of the classic B2B examples for reference points here. The first one is from HubSpot, the second one is from Salesforce. They do a great job at high converting pricing tiers.

Hubspot Pricing Page

SalesForce pricing page

In both of the examples above, it’s very clear as to what you are getting with the different pricing tiers. The CTA’s are contrasting in color versus the rest of the page, and the prices are clearly stated.

If you’re looking for test ideas and you don’t think your design hits the mark there, you might want to test alternative designs.

Align your pricing with buyer personas.

The idea here is to articulate your pricing tiers in a way that resonates with the customer’s perception of their own business. For example, ‘professional’ and ‘enterprise’ are both terms that both HubSpot and Salesforce use, and it’s very infrequently that people arrive on either of these pricing pages and get confused between which one they have to pick.

The pricing tiers are articulated and match how the user perceives their business. This helps the user not get stuck trying to choose between options.

Use a single core value metric

I recommend scaling your pricing tiers to a ‘single core value metric’. This is a single metric the user understands and reflects the value they get from the platform as they scale.

To take a HubSpot example, the pricing is based on a number of contacts, and the user intuitively understands that as they have more contacts in HubSpot, the pricing increases because the value to them increases as well.

So if you’re looking at your pricing pages and want to improve conversion there and find that your pricing tiers aren’t necessarily consistent with the buyer persona or you’re not clearly articulating a single core value metric, you may want to test reframing some of that pricing, rearticulating it, and comparing that to your current baseline.

Eliminate multiple audiences for a single page

Let’s take a look at the example above. Can you spot the problem?

Right here we’re looking at actually two different audiences being targeted, and two completely different buyer journeys being crammed into a single pricing page; a single web experience.

The basic and premium options are targeted towards small or medium-sized businesses and organizations, and the signup flow is self-registration; it occurs completely through the website.

But as you can see, they’re also trying to target enterprise customers through ‘request a demo’, and speaking to someone on the inside sales team that has a completely different experience and audience.

That should set off some alarms. If you’re in the business of driving conversions, competing calls to action, audiences, and buyer journeys on a single page does have a really negative impact on your conversion rate.

Solution: Optimize through personalization

How can we improve the experience of a pricing page with multiple buyer personas?

If you are able to identify the nature of that account or traffic coming into the site, you can show a unique experience for that specific audience.

For example, target SMBs based on previous browsing behavior and highlight the self-signup flow. Alternatively, through firmographic third party integrations, identify if a visitor is coming from an Apple or Microsoft, and really highlight the enterprise plan and the benefits for that customer.

Through personalizing the experience, the decision-making process is simplified for the visitor, and you’ll see an increase in conversions.

Clear Calls to Action

It’s really important on pricing pages to set clear expectations on the call to action as to what happens when the user clicks a button. In the HubSpot example, somewhat non-traditionally, they use two calls to action.

But in this case, they are differentiated both in design as well as the expectations. One is about trying it, engaging in the free trial. One is about signing up.

Salesforce is very clear that when you click on that button, you start the free trial process.

So if the expectation isn’t clear in your call to action language, that might be something that you want to test.

Offer human help

Now even if you get all of this right, you’re going to run into times where the user is still stuck staring at the pricing page and can’t make a decision. If you do have that happening, again, that’s really high-value traffic that you don’t necessarily want to lose.

If it’s worth it to you, you might want to test intervening with human help.

Offer to intervene, give them whatever information they need to potentially get that conversion, get them across the line!

There are a couple of ways you can go about this. Salesforce, after a couple seconds, pops up a modal window offering to put you in front of a live agent.

Alternatively, if you have chat already on the site, certainly you could pop that chat window when the user’s stuck.

Try a chat window by Olark.

Keep things simple

The reality is that people don’t read content, at best they skim. Furthurmore, no one wants to read a complicated piece of content.

The same concept goes for your pricing page. Keep it as simple and easy to understand as possible. You should be always asking your self ‘what can we do to simplify this page’.

Help Scout has one of the most simple pricing pages - grow your SaaS revenue with Stimulead

Look at the HelpScout pricing page above. It’s a simple price and sign up box. There is no confusion for the customer, the action for them to take is right in front of them.

Some companies need tiered pricing given the complexity of their offerings. Yet, if some A/B tests support increased conversions and your bottom line is not affected, consider dropping the multiple price points.

Highlight your unique values

Many times users are comparing various vendors for a specific product across some specific criteria. Once you know that specific criteria for your product, make it very obvious. If you know

If you know price is a big factor, you should it as the first thing people see on the page. If you are a storage company like Box, make the storage limits one of the first things people see.

Box pricing page

In many instances people don’t even know what they want. In the classic marketing book ‘Predictably Irrational’ by Dan Ariely he states, “Most people don’t know what they want unless they see it in context”. For example, people don’t know what basketball shoe they should buy until they see it on a professional. 

Same goes for marketing a pricing page. Many people won’t know what are the important factors to consider. It’s up to you spell it out for your customers and make the most important features front and center.

Suggest Plans to Users

It can often times be beneficial to push users towards a certain plan. By doing so you are reducing purchase friction and making it easy for users to make a decision.

Spotify pricing page

Now the question becomes which plan to recommend. There is no clear cut answer to this question, but here are a few things to consider.

  • Consider data known data about a user. Using the FunnelEnvy platform, you can bring in Marketo or Salesforce data into your pricing page tests. This gives you the ability to personalize the pricing page depending on the user/accounts. As a basic test, try changing the recommendation based on company size!
  • Recommend the most expensive option. While it is unrealistic that the majority of people chose that option, you can expect people to choose the second most expensive. This is advantageous if people are often opting for your least expensive option, and you want to incentivise them to upgrade.
  • Free Trial. While the free trial isn’t going to bring you the most money up front, it does have the least amount of friction. If you can work out the numbers, pushing people to a free trial might be your best option.

Address Fears

In the world of sales there is the concept of FUD. This stands for fear, uncertainties, and doubts. These FUDs come out when a customer is making a purchase, the bigger the purchase the greater opportunity for it to arise.

The best way to address FUD is to address it up front on the pricing page. To get started, write down all the possible fears, uncertainties, and doubts that people might have. Then write down your response to how to handle the FUD.

Here are some examples.

  1. Customer: I won’t get the ROI from this software. Response: “Average customers increase revenue by 34% with the software.”
  2. Customer: The software will be difficult to implement. Response: “We offer free implementation support to guarentee you get up and running”.

See how the customer will feel much more at ease after their fears are addressed.

SumoLogic Pricing Table

See how SumoLogic offers a free trial to reduce fears that users won’t get any value back from signing up.

Show Validation

It’s important that customers know other companies use and have success with your software. This validation helps to reduce fear for the customer about spending their money.

The easiest way to show validation is through quotes. See below how SumoLogic reduces fear that users won’t be able to get the software into production by showing a quote.

Customer Quote from SumoLogic

If you want to have the most relevant quote for a particular visitor, we recommend using personalization to show a quote based on a user industry. For example, if you know a visitor works in the travel industry, you could show a quote from someone at AirBnB.

Incentives Longer Commitments

It’s always beneficial to have customers pay for year-long commitments up front. This keeps them locked in for longer, and make it impossible to stop after only a month. While there might be some conversion drop-off for those who don’t want to pay at once, the overall benefit to your business will be tremendous.

Let’s take a look at some examples.

In this example from Dropbox, you can see that the pricing defaults to annual billing.

Dropbox Annual Billing

However, you can also switch to monthly billing, although it costs more per month.

Dropbox Monthly Billing

The goal here is to push people into the yearly billing and longer commitment.

Below is a similar example from Sumo. In this pricing page, they subtly say “paid annually” under the monthly price. While it can be construed as a ‘dirty trick’ to make someone think they are paying a monthly rate, this practice is quite common with pricing pages.

AppSumo Pricing Page

 

Conclusion

I hope you can use some of these tips in your own pricing pages. If you have any questions about how to best optimize your pricing page, please let us know in the comments, and we’ll be sure to give you some tailored suggestions.

By |2018-09-28T15:35:33-07:00May 11th, 2017|B2B|0 Comments

Incorporating Account-Based Personalization Into Your Marketing Strategy

Casting a wide net in search of business-to-business (B2B) customers isn’t the right strategy for every company. Rather than spending resources on a larger market, find out why a personalized approach that targets specific accounts could better help your business achieve its sales goals.

If you’ve never used account-based marketing (ABM) before, there’s never been a better time to start. B2B companies with highly targeted audiences use ABM to create effective sales funnels that drive results. Find out how to take this marketing strategy to the next level with account-based personalization, and learn how it can help you meet high-reaching objectives.

Define Your Market

Image via Bigstock

One of the key differences between traditional digital marketing and digital ABM is that the former casts a wide net, while the latter considers individual accounts to be their own markets. To make the most of ABM, you’ll need to break your pool of both current and prospective clients into individual markets.

Doing this offers ample opportunity for personalization. Since you’ll work to build a marketing strategy for each client individually, you’ll customize digital campaigns, sales goals, and even relationship structures. Do the necessary research for each major account you want to win, and you can easily define and optimize your market.

For example, email marketing company Strongview used account-based personalization to define its target market and provide custom content with different greetings and unique images for each industry targeted.. As a result, the company experienced a 42 percent increase in web traffic, 29 percent increase in conversions from previously inactive accounts, and a 42 percent increase in engagement from target accounts.

Create a Personalized Experience for Each Account

With ABM software, you can even personalize website content for each account you’re targeting.

Easy-to-use personalization features track IP addresses for your target customers and enable your website to serve custom content to users from these select IP addresses. Doing this increases the chances that you’ll give representatives from each account exactly what they want to see, whether they’re searching for an answer to a question or they’re ready to make a purchase.

Integrate your ABM initiatives with marketing automation and sales platforms so you can easily follow up with the clients you want to land. Most ABM platforms offer seamless integrations with select platforms. Doing this automatically incorporates your target customers into each step of your marketing strategy, so you won’t miss the opportunity to follow up at key intervals.

Identify the Key Players

As you begin to develop an ABM strategy, it’s important to remember that each account or market consists of several key players. After all, most companies seek a consensus before reaching a decision, and not every person at the table will respond to marketing messages in the same way. That’s why it’s essential to identify the key decision-makers for each account and understand how best to get through to each one.

For instance, the marketing director, project manager, and CEO will each analyze your sales pitch from a different perspective. If you need all of these major players to sign off before greenlighting your project, then you need to tailor your messages to each one with headers, pictures, and white papers.

Find out who the key players are by doing basic research on the company’s website or on LinkedIn. As you shape each personalized account, review the key players with your team during internal meetings and redraft your list of target employees as necessary.

Use Retargeting

3D illustration of behavioral retargeting principle over white background.

Just because you don’t generate warm leads the first time you get the attention of prospective clients doesn’t mean you should cross them off your list. Instead of abandoning hard-to-get clients, retarget them instead.

Retargeting is a key component of ABM, as it identifies clients who have engaged with your content previously and then works to place your content in front of their eyes again. Many ABM platforms utilize ad-based retargeting strategies that serve ads to users who have previously visited your website or clicked on your content.

Some platforms even automatically provide personalized content that prompts conversions and drives sales after detecting buying signals. With this kind of personalized power, you can strike while the iron is hot and land the clients you’ve been pursuing at the precise moment they’re ready to buy.

Measure Your Results

When you use a marketing platform like Funnel Envy, Google Analytics, or a combination of both, you can easily measure the results of your ABM strategy. Social tracking tools like Kissmetrics also enable you to monitor engagement across platforms to ensure that you’ve targeted the right players.

In addition, you can quickly collect metrics that help you determine the return on investment (ROI) for each campaign. Since you’ve already done research to determine how much each account is worth to your business, you can easily do the math to calculate your return. As Alterra Group states, most executives look for revenue growth over any other measure of ROI.

By knowing campaign ROI, you’ll reduce risk and wasted resources. Don’t let a generic marketing strategy deliver results that are less than optimal. Take advantage of FunnelEnvy’s account-based personalization tool, and find out for yourself how this strategy can help you take your B2B sales to the next level.

By |2018-01-03T19:24:43-08:00May 9th, 2017|B2B|0 Comments
Go to Top